Trinity Guardrail to Undergo Further Testing in Virginia
Trinity Industries Inc.’s guardrail system will undergo additional crash testing by the state of Virginia, raising new questions about a device on roadways across the country.
Some of Virginia’s six proposed tests on the ET-Plus, scheduled to begin in mid-September, will be different than those previously conducted for the U.S. government, according to documents reviewed by Bloomberg News.
RELATED: Trinity Industries Must Pay $663 Million in Guardrail Defect Case
Trinity said in an Aug. 27 statement disclosing the tests that it does “not believe additional tests are needed.” In March, amid allegations the system was unsafe, the ET-Plus passed a series of eight crash tests overseen by the Federal Highway Administration, the government agency that helps regulate highway hardware.
Trinity has not seen a formal test plan from Virginia, company spokesman Jeff Eller said in a phone interview. Tamara Rollison, a spokeswoman for the state's transportation department, confirmed the new testing but declined to comment on details.
Two of the proposed tests involve a vehicle hitting the end of the ET-Plus at a slight angle, according to the documents. Trinity’s rivals have said the system is most likely to malfunction when a car hits the end of it at such angles.
RELATED: Guardrail Maker Defrauded US of $175 Million and Created Hazard, Jury Says
FHWA “will be monitoring the results” of Virginia’s tests, spokeswoman Jane Mellow said in an e-mail.
The ET-Plus is meant to act like a roadside shock absorber that blunts the ends of guardrails. More than 20 lawsuits allege that a modified version of the system locks up when hit, spearing through crashing cars instead of helping slow them down. About 200,000 of the units are installed along U.S. roadways, FHWA has said.
Last year, Virginia joined a whistle-blower lawsuit against Trinity alleging the company cheated taxpayers by failing to disclose changes it made to the system. The company sold thousands of unapproved and potentially dangerous highway guardrail devices to the state, according to the complaint.
Trinity also is appealing a $663 million federal fraud judgment against the company for its lack of disclosure of the ET-Plus changes.
“The ET-Plus system has been successfully crash tested more times than any product of its kind,” the Dallas-based company said in its statement.
